Fremont Digester Public Hearing 11/20 – How it Effects Holton and Muskegon County – Video and Public Comment

by Andy O'Riley | Nov 21, 2024 | Muskegon Metro Area News

I’d like to begin by saying that our video today has one edit.  You’ll see a crowd pan at the beginning to give you the scope of the room, and from there, it’s as it happened at the Fremont Library on the night of November 20th.  Concerned Citizens gathered with multiple representatives from EGLE to learn more about the Digester in Fremont and the impact that’s not really known about the “digestate” that comes from the end of the process.  I was invited to record the meeting by people leading the charge against granting the permit as it’s currently written.  The objection is to the unknown long-term effects of the byproducts if they are spread on the ground and used as fertilizer.  The meeting is here for you to view and below the video, you will find the letter I submitted to EGLE as time ran out and I was unable to make public comment.  The letter written below is editorial.  You may or may not agree.  Again, it’s my feelings being expressed to the State in the letter.

 

This is the letter to EGLE that I submitted this morning. 

 

Public Comment Fremont Digester – 11/20/24

Thank you for my 3 minutes to speak, my name is Andy O’Riley and I am a publisher from Muskegon County, and most recently the first runner up in a County Commissioner race. My comment tonight has a couple of components.

First off, my job as a publisher takes me into areas that are uncharted territory for me. Learning over the last year or so about the immense level of problems we have in and around Muskegon County, my first comment is to the people of Fremont. My friends and neighbors, you want nothing to do with the levels of hurt and misery I have seen and felt from the people I have spoken to who’ve been affected by the areas that have been contaminated over the years in our county. To speak specifically to every story I have heard about the impact on people, land, water and the long term problems that they and their children have endured and it’s nothing but heartbreak and misery. I personally make every effort in my work to show Muskegon County the better side of itself in all that we publish and to do that while an already marginalized community keeps getting told “We test every 5 years” on known sites that are still preventing aquatic life from coming back to some area creeks, it’s remarkably difficult…. and to my own fault, the sugar coated things I focus on sure seem trivial. I didn’t come in first runner up in that quest to be a county commissioner for glory fame or money, I truly owe the people of Muskegon everything and to see another community at the risk of decades of destruction because of a poorly written permit or a permit granted with too many unknowns, I beg EGEL to deny this permit until it’s rock solid and understood what’s coming out of it. There’s proof in Walkerville of the damage that can be done, and to see this beautiful community destroyed by “what could be beneficial” isn’t worth the risk. Fremont, you are surrounded by communities that can show you physically the devastation that can come.

Next, I’d like to address the process. I believe that EGLE is an agency that’s there to help. I also understand that the process is technical and involves many layers. This is a problem for so many as they are unable to understand the language you use and the process it takes to come to a decision. I understand the checks and balances. I understand the idea of getting it right and I also understand that business needs to operate. “We’ll be back in 5 years to test again.” Listen to that through the ears of a mom who’s got kids with cognitive impairments in school or a family that continues to see cancer and other diseases pop up. The jargon, the process and the time are insults. Please, find a way to speak in plain English. Please find a way to communicate in areas that barely have their own media if any at all.

Finally…the exhaustion. People in Muskegon County are tired. They are tired of being ignored. They are tired of hearing that yet again some VFW is hosting a benefit for someone with cancer or seeing some kid off to Helen DeVos Children’s Hospital to find out what’s wrong. Fremont has been an amazingly self-sufficient community. The agriculture here is essential and part of the fabric of everything that’s going right. To jeopardize that because you were told “Oh ya, this stuff is fine” is a risk that’s not worth taking. I again ask that for the people of Muskegon County, Oceana County and Newaygo County, where all of this unknown digestate is being spread, that this permit is denied until there is clarity of who’s operating it. Their qualifications and their commitment to safety and stewardship of our collective environment is their first priority backed by a permit that is as powerful as it can be and monitored by third party researchers at the cost of the operator. It’s a cost of doing good business to make sure your stewardship is there. They should understand that and be compliant.
With all due respect and appreciation for you taking the time to hear my thoughts,

Andy O’Riley
Twin Lake MI

Take action?  

CLICK HERE TO VISIT EGLE – THE MiENVIRO PORTAL.  There’s a registration process but once you complete that, public comment is open until November 27th

CLICK HERE TO VISIT THE FREMONT DIGESTER AND LAGOON UPDATES FACEBOOK GROUP

MUSKEGON CHANNEL VISIT TO SEE THE DAMAGE IN WALKERVILLE.  Bonus film of a farmer in Brighton who’s lost it all. 

MUSKEGON CHANNEL STORY ON THE LIFLESS AREAS OF THE BLACK CREEK

 

Related Stories