It probably wouldn’t come as a surprise to some of you to learn that I’ve been a huge fan of Edgar Allan Poe since I was a teenager. In fact, it was my fascination with his dark and foreboding stories that steered me in the direction of gothic novels. Of course, then my curiosity led to other forbidden or mysterious subjects usually in the form of research. Yet my love of Poe has never wavered. So when I found out that the Edgar Allan Poe Speakeasy, a pop-up theater experience; would be in town featuring his works, I knew this was a must-see. If this was the 1880s, I might have actually swooned at the prospect. I purchased my ticket right away and after a little mix-up with ticket access and the cancellation of the first show, I made it, dressed in my favorite Gothic attire. Today I’d like to share a little bit of that experience with you as well as give a little history about the master of the macabre himself.
If you haven’t heard of these events currently making their way around the country, these unique pop-up plays, held in darkly-lit speakeasy-themed venues, are focused solely on his stories. Actors dressed in Victorian clothing tell the tales while the audience sips gothic-inspired cocktails paired to each one. The speakeasy website describes it as an immersive spell-binding take on Poe’s stories told with attention to the macabre nature that Poe’s stories envision. The Poe Speakeasy experiences are the creation of Julia Tirinnanzi who also tours with one of five troupes in various cities. The producer is Ryan Austin Wieczorek of Midnight Creatives out of Tampa, Florida. 
Poe is remembered for his morbid stories and poems worldwide. The horror themes evoked within his works remain virtually unrivaled in fiction and many of his works, including “The Fall of the House of Usher,” and “The Tell-Tale Heart,” are literary classics. Murders in the Rue Morgue was instrumental in creating the detective story and The Raven is considered to be one of the best-known poems in American literature.
Like his stories, Poe’s life is rather mysterious, with the lines between fact and fiction becoming blurred since his death. Poe was born on January 19, 1809 in Boston Massachusetts to Elizabeth Arnold Poe and David Poe Jr., who were both Baltimore actors. Edgar never really knew his biological parents as father left the family when Edgar was young and his mother died from tuberculosis when he was only two. Poe was a talented poet early on and by 13 his talent was being noticed.
Poe attended the University of Virginia until lack of funds forced him to quit. He published his first book in 1827 around the time that he was enlisted in the army. After this he obtained an appointment to West Point, but was let go shortly after. After this he began writing full-time. After leaving West Point, he published his third book. He lived at various times in New York City, Baltimore, Philadelphia, and Richmond in order to find writing opportunities. Unable to find work, he struggled to make ends meet, and lived in poverty until he won a writing contest. This was a turning point for him and he was able to publish more short stories.
In 1836 he published his poem “the Raven” which was an instant success. The poem’s main theme revolves around the loss of great love as well as death, a common theme with much of Poe’s work. Poe’s short story “The Black Cat” was published in 1843 in The Saturday Evening Post. The story was later included in the 1845 short story collection, Tales by Edgar Allan Poe. This rather gruesome tale descends into murder and madness as well as themes of guilt and remorse. The masque of the red death was first published in 1842 as “The mask of the red death: A fantasy” in Graham’s Magazine. It has been adapted many times over the years. The storyline follows a Prince’s attempts to avoid a dangerous plague. He and other nobles decide to hold a masquerade ball to hide from the plaque. The story may at the core represent mortality and the fragility of life. “The Tell-tale heart,” one of Poe’s best known stories, was published in 1843 in The Pioneer in January 1843. It is revered as iconic within the Gothic fiction genre. The storyline involves elements of murder, guilt as well as insanity.
It has been over a century and a half since Edgar Allan Poe left this world but yet we are still entranced by his stories, Muskegonites included. Several hundred eager patrons attended the speakeasy event at Fricano’s restaurant, 1050 W. Western Avenue, Suite 200, in Muskegon. In the darkened event center that been transformed into a gothic speakeasy, four of Poe’s most famous stories are told with macabre dramatic flair: The tell-tale heart, the masque of the red death, the black cat and of course…the Raven.
I opted to go the 6 p.m. showing, although I got there later than I planned. Poe’s popularity was clearly evident, judging by the near-capacity seating. I scanned the room to find a spot, finding one about midway in. It wasn’t optimal but I could still see most of the stage. One can usually tell upon first entering an event if it is going to live up to your expectations or not. Much to my Poe-lover’s delight, it did not disappoint. Right at the start, the vibe was dark, foreboding and thrilling, as one would hope a telling of a Poe’s story would be.

The stage, although simple, was fitting; the soft glow of the candles at the front were reminiscent of bygone days and the overhead stage lights changed color from story to story and cast eerie shadows on the backdrop; creating a spell-binding mood. I did snap a few photos of each scene. The story-telling was performed by four actors, who also doubled as servers and hosts as well as stage hands. The performances were done with great pathos and depth with each actor telling the stories in their own unique style. The addition of a historical oral snapshot of Poe’s chaotic life intertwined with the dark themes of the stories caught the audience up in a shadowy web, as if seeing the darkness inside Poe’s mind. In between scene changes, the mood was kept light and fun, the narrator engaging the audience with humor. A few minutes into the Act I, the first cocktail made its round; followed by three more as the stories were told. I had forgotten to check the website to see what the drinks were ahead of time, and I hoped they would be something really cool. I was not disappointed. They were unusual and distinctive and helped convey the gothic theme. The first drink was called the Pale Blue Eye; which kind of threw me for a minute when I first looked at it in the darkened room. “Is that an eyeball?” I thought. The blueberry garnish did pass reasonably well as an eyeball in the dim light. How deliciously ghastly! It was quite good…light and crisp. Next round was the Masque of the Red Death; with Cheery Heering from Denmark, to give it the color of blood (yummy) and Benedictine liquor from France. This cocktail was also quite enjoyable. They certainly did not slouch on the ingredients, which included imported liquors. The interesting fact about the Benedictine is that its recipe is a closely guarded secret, only known by a handful of people. Next was Poe’s favorite drink, Edgar’s Twisted Brand 7Milk Punch, topped with a star anise. While I love Poe, I did not love this because of the strong anise flavor so didn’t drink it. Anise only belongs on pizza as far as I’m concerned (don’t get me started on the pineapple debate). The finale was a black and gold cocktail called The Nevermore to go along with the reading of “The Raven,” which I also liked. Again this was made with some high-end imported ingredients.
If you like live theater, cocktails, and gothic horror, be sure to check it out if it comes to your town or comes back to Muskegon! I thoroughly enjoyed this experience and would definitely go again. The narrator was greeting guests as they left and was kind enough to take a selfie with me. Unfortunately I didn’t get her name as she had to rush back to start the next show. My photos didn’t turn out too shabby, check them out at the bottom of the article. My only caveat for anyone going (hindsight and all that) is to make sure you eat dinner first as the event lasts about 90 minutes and the alcoholic beverages are good-sized. Also make sure you have a ride home; Uber, cab, friend, etc. I live within walking distance of the venue, but my daughter came to pick me up anyway. As I left, there was a line out the door and down the stairs waiting for the next show. No doubt that Poe would be pleased that that his chilling masterpieces are still being enjoyed by so many.
Poe died on October 7, 1849, Baltimore, Maryland. Poe’s cause of death is unknown. Theories include acute alcoholism, brain tumor, “brain congestion” as well as others. However, it is likely that alcoholism played some part in his early demise.
“The boundaries which divide life from death are at best shadowy and vague. Who shall say where the one ends, and where the other begins?
Indeed. Poe has shed his tortured mortal coil, but his stories live on…to thrill, to entertain….maybe even to haunt.
The Poe Speakeasy experience will be in select cities with limited engagement runs in 2025. Some of the cities they’ve already played in addition to Muskegon, were North Hollywood, CA; Fort Myers, FLA, New Orleans, LA; Boca Raton, FLA, and Reno, Nevada. As of this writing, they have events booked from August until October, 2025 in cities all around the U.S. This is a 21 and up event and is limited to two days only. Reservations are restricted to a small number of guests.
For more information on the event, go to the “Edgar Allan Poe Speakeasy” https://www.edgarallanpoebar.com/
On Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/edgarallanpoebar
Contact email: edgarallanpoebar@gmail.com
Thank you for watching the Muskegon Channel. See you next time on Paranormal Muskegon. Until then, stay curious and stay…Spooky!
Have a paranormal story you would like to hear, share or know someone has had a paranormal experience, unusual ability, or other inexplicable involvement with the unknown, contact me at mariehelena777@gmail.com or on facebook: www.facebook.com/paranormalmuskegon.
To read more about some of Muskegon’s haunted history; check out my book: Haunted Muskegon – Arcadia Publishing or Haunted Newaygo County also through Arcadia Publishing for more local Michigan ghost stories.
Sources:
Barzun, Jacques & Thomas Ollive Mabbot. “Edgar Allan Poe.” Britannica website. Updated July 2, 2025. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Edgar-Allan-Poe. Accessed August 19, 2025.
Biography.com Editors. “Edgar Allan Poe.” Biography.com. website. Updated October 24, 2023. https://www.biography.com/authors-writers/edgar-allan-poe. Accessed August 19, 2025.
“The Masque of the red death.” Poestories.com. An exploration of the short stories of Edgar Allan Poe. https://poestories.com/read/masque 2025. accessed August 19, 2025.
“The Masque of the red death.” Wikipedia. Edited August 3, 2025. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Masque_of_the_Red_Death. Accessed August 19, 2025.
“The tell-tale heart.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tell-Tale_Heart Wikipedia. 2025. Accessed August 19, 2025.
Kudakis, Kay. “The Edgar Allan Poe Speakeasy at the Revolution Stage Company.” Broadwayworld.com. July 2, 2024. https://www.broadwayworld.com/palm-springs/article/Review-THE-EDGAR-ALLAN-POE-SPEAKEASY-at-Revolution-Stage-Company-20240701 Accessed August 20, 2025.
Magyaries, Kelly. “What the #$@! Do I do with this? Benedictine: What it is and how to use it.” Liquor.com. February 25, 2021. https://www.liquor.com/benedictine-cocktail-recipes-5114279 Accessed August 20, 2025.
Graham, Colleen. “What is Cherry Heering Liqueur? A guide to buying, drinking and cooking with Cherry Heering Liqueur.” The SpruceEats.com. “https://www.thespruceeats.com/what-is-cherry-heering-760236. Accessed August 20, 2025.












