Hello all you lovers of the strange, weird and mysterious, you’ve probably all heard about the Bermuda Triangle. If you have, then some of this might be familiar to you. But if you haven’t, it is a stretch of ocean running between Florida, Bermuda and Puerto Rico, where numerous ships, aircraft, and people have vanished without a trace. In fact, the Bermuda triangle is only one of many places around the globe where bizarre things are said to happen…including one right here on the shores of the mitten state.
Yes, folks, Michigan has its own weird triangle. There are actually more shipwrecks or disappearances within the Great Lakes than the Bermuda Triangle, including over 1,500 in Lake Michigan alone.
Our triangle goes from Manitowoc, Wisconsin, across Lake Michigan to Ludington and south to Benton Harbor. Within this area, ships travel back and forth between ports along the lake, so they have to cross through this triangle. Unfortunately some of them never make it to their destinations.
Lake Michigan is the only great lake entirely within United States boundaries. It has 1,600 miles of shoreline, is 280 feet deep and 920 feet at its deepest part. This lake is anything but typical and has similarities to a small ocean. While beautiful and serene on the surface, it can be deadly; especially for the unwary. Its mood can change at a moment’s notice; with sudden squalls and high winds that can throw ships around like toys, drench them in powerful massive waves or pull swimmers beneath the surface in treacherous undertows.
The schooner, Rouse-Simmons, also known as the Christmas Tree ship, owned by Charles Hackley, of Muskegon, might have been one of the Michigan triangle’s first victims. It happened in November, 1891 when the schooner set sail with a crew of seven men to pick up lumber from the mills. Not too long after setting sail, the ship encountered a horrific galestorm that came up during the night foundered in the icy waters. A search party was sent out; however no trace of it or the crew was seen. It seemed to have completely disappeared.
Unfortunately this was not an isolated incident and more tragic wrecks happened over the years, claiming many lives in the process.
While it’s the general consensus that bad weather is the most likely culprit for most of these, some believe that weather alone can’t account for the destruction of so many ships, and that the Michigan triangle is somehow to blame. At over 1,500, the sheer number of wrecks is staggering as is the fact that only around 400 have been recovered as of yet.
Yet the lake gets stranger because…at the bottom are ancient stone structures arranged in a circle and at the center is a large stone with what appears to be a mastodon carved into it. If you didn’t know, Mastodons were large animals that once roamed the Great Lakes region about 12,000 years ago. The stones, which some are calling the Michigan Stonehedge, were discovered in 2007. They are believed to be 9-10 thousand years old but as they have not been fully investigated, their age is anybody’s guess. No one even knows their actual location. However, it has been suggested that they are the source for the area’s odd weather patterns and shipwrecks.
There are a number of theories to explain the high number of lake disasters in addition to weather or the rock formation, from electromagnetic interference; paranormal forces and even UFOs. Another is magnetic fluctuations between true north and magnetic north. Others theorize that the triangle is a negative energy vortex. Vortexes create a powerful sacred energy and are usually positive but others emit dangerous negative energy. Ley lines are also said to be the site of energy vortexes and Lake Michigan does have a ley line running through its center.
With so many shipwrecks and strange anomalies happening with no clear answers, it’s understandable why some people would feel there is something mysterious behind them. Lake Michigan continues to be used in travel and recreation by thousands of people every day, so it seems reasonable to investigate these incidents further to hopefully prevent any further tragedies.
I don’t know about you, but I think if there are negative vortexes or some sort of paranormal forces in the triangle capable of sending ships to the bottom of the lake or making them disappear completely, people would like to know about it. After all, there may be a darker reason that we Michiganders call our winter lake storms, Witch Gales.
If you’d like to read more about Muskegon’s Christmas tree ship as well as some other ghost stories, especially since its spooky season, check out my book, “Haunted Muskegon,” available at most bookstores or at Arcadia Publishing.
Thank you for watching the Muskegon Channel. See you next time on Paranormal Muskegon! Until then, stay curious and stay…spooky. Happy Halloween!
Sources: “Lake Michigan Triangle.” Wikipedia. September 20, 2025. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Michigan_Triangle Accessed October 16, 2025.
“9,000-Year-old Stonehedge-like structure found under Lake Michigan.” The Archeologist. Civilizations of the world, website. January 24, 2023. https://www.thearchaeologist.org/blog/9000-year-old-stonehenge-like-structure-found-under-lake-michigan Accessed October 16, 2025.
Cisneros, Marie Helena. “Unlucky horseshoe and other bad omens: Ghost of the Christmas Tree Ship” Haunted Muskegon. Historypress.com. Published by Haunted America, a division of the History Press. Pg 76. Charleston, N.C. 2022.
Have a paranormal story you would like to hear, share or know someone has had a paranormal experience, unusual ability, or other inexplicable involvement with the unknown, contact me at mariehelena777@gmail.com or on facebook: www.facebook.com/paranormalmuskegon.
To read more about some of Muskegon’s haunted history; check out my book: Haunted Muskegon – Arcadia Publishing or Haunted Newaygo County also through Arcadia Publishing for more local Michigan ghost stories.












