“Play it Straight” – The Actors Workshop of West Michigan Debuts Play – Aaron Petersen Reports

by Andy O'Riley | Mar 19, 2026 | Entertainment

If you are as infatuated with the arts and culture scene here in Muskegon as I am (obligatory or otherwise; I’m a bit of both), you will know that the LGBTQ+ community has experienced a massive surge in advocacy, with Muskegon Pride Festival continually growing in popularity with every passing summer since its inception along with multiple resources and initiatives put in place to directly support LGBTQ+ citizens. I state much of this to preface the rest of this article with this: this playwright contains many characters of unique orientations within its script, but it was never truly the focal point of Play It Straight.

Created by playwright Richard Winters, Kerri Yund, and Gary Wright, the first of whom has travelled to see Muskegon’s iteration of this compelling, personal love letter to educational values and being oneself, Director Adam Bell was immediately interested in the script, having compiled many of his initial cast members from The Actors’ Workshop of West Michigan.

“I was sold on it, but I don’t necessarily trust my judgment,” said Bell, who also plays the superintendent in the play. “Because it speaks to themes about the education system. It’s kind of a love letter to the public-school teacher. My mom was a public-school teacher, so it spoke to me.” straight 1

The journey to this point, however, was quite arduous. With the play having been fully cast 28 months prior to its initial premiere along with receiving rights to the script, the gears were set in motion for a premiere in summer of 2025 during Muskegon Pride Festival, but it was ultimately put on hold due to many of the cast members at the time having undergone graduation from high school when the play was intended to premiere.
“It kind of got put on the back burner, but I never stopped looking for a place to do it,” Bell had mentioned. “And we partnered here with The Corner; we do our shows here now.”

With an exclusive preview of the rehearsals, I can happily say I was blown away by the actors’ seamless chemistry, dedication to ensuring this script is portrayed accurately, and their innate sense of togetherness along with an immersive and personally visceral story that speaks to many truths about modern society. With many of the actors having been picked for their respective roles just over a week ago, it feels surreal knowing how much progress the production team and cast have made to make the deadline for opening night. With some of the original cast members reprising their roles from when the play was supposed to premiere over the previous summer, they believe the timing of this play couldn’t be better. 

“Well, it’s just so timely,” said Julie Bratton, starring as Ms. Hewitt in the play. “Even though this is like a fictionalized account, it kind of reflects things that are sort of happening in some school districts pretty close to here.”
With six of the cast members being members of the LGBTQ+ community, this play immediately spoke to those of whom have struggled with coming out to their friends and families.
“I didn’t get the cast I wanted. I got the cast I was supposed to have,” said Bell. “I’ve always said my casting director resides upstairs, and I put a lot of faith in that.”
While resonating deeply with cast members of unique backgrounds, it also spoke to cast members who come from a more traditional background.

“For me, it’s really special,” said Gabi Tomes, one of the lead cast members playing Hope Stern. “I went to a religious school, so that’s something that we weren’t even allowed to think of.”
“It makes people think there are obvious barriers in understanding and semantics between groups of people,” said David Cato, one of the cast members who also came from a more traditional household playing as Chris Stern. “This sort of represents sympathetic and unsympathetic ways of looking at them. Because there are several points in this play where a simple change of a turn off phrase or a simple understanding would have solved all of the conflicts here.”

Taking place over the span of a day in a high school drama class, the class instructor is faced with the dilemma of a father, who happens to be a local police officer, of a pair of students forcibly removing his children from the teacher’s classroom over a misunderstanding. All the while, one of the children, who is secretly gay to all but those within the drama classroom setting (teacher included), is faced with the dilemma of standing up for her teacher while attempting to keep their sexuality concealed from their conservative father.

straight 2“[The teacher] has a drama class and there are non-binary kids in his class,” Bell mentioned, explaining the primary conflict of the plot. “One of them is out and their parents know about it. So, there’s no problem with the district, but there’s one student that is secretly and is out in class, but not elsewhere… The teacher has kept their [sexuality] secret, but an event happens where it’s found out by administration, and so they have to tell this student’s conservative father that their daughter is gay.”

The advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights was never intended to be the primary subject of the story, but Muskegon’s LGBTQ+ community has seen the inadvertent, but very much positive, representation of said individuals by endorsing the upcoming play. The aforementioned nonprofit, Muskegon Pride, will be receiving all box office profits from opening night to help fund their events and their continued support for the community.
“I’ve been out of the closet since I was about 13 years old, said Rikki Ridout, one of the primary cast members who plays CJ Stern. “I had an uncle who passed away due to the AIDS epidemic, so my family was adjusted to queerness; however, there was still a lot of internalized homophobia and transphobia that lingered in the household due to outdated ideologies. I spent a lot of time in my family, unpacking that… I’m very lucky because my family did take those criticisms and they took them to heart and they worked on it, and [if] you had a 70-year-old immigrant grandmother, you would be a little bit scared to explain to her what a nonbinary person was… Queer education is something that means a lot to me, and I feel like this show shows a lot of trouble, inner turmoil, [and] internalized homophobia.”

 

 

The play already predicts to have a sold-out crowd on opening night, with over 120 tickets sold as of this past Monday for the premiere.  “I told the actors too that the difficult thing is going to be [that] you’re going to have this huge full house on Friday night, and then it’s going to be a drop on the second night,” Bell mentioned. “It’s possible that you will get vocal, and maybe even applause reactions to some lines in this show, because they resonate so strongly that with this community that you’re not going to get on any other night of the show.”

 

Play It Straight will be premiering tomorrow night at 7pm at The Stage at the Corner in Downtown Muskegon at 280 W. Muskegon Ave., with subsequent performances following on Mar. 21, 27, and 28.
“For me, what would be the most fulfilling is to reach kids who are living this right now,’ Tomes mentioned. “To reach actual high schoolers who are struggling with that idea of “can I come out and be accepted as who I am?’ That is what my character deals with specifically is being closeted and being forced out of the closet.”

To learn more about the play or book your tickets to see it live, please visit https://awwm.ludus.com/index.php.

Related Stories